With the release of Logan just around the corner, I thought I’d deliver my honest
opinion on each of the X-Men films.
Before I start, I should say I am not a comic-book reader, although I have read about
the source material and I have watched the 1992 animated series, which I heard,
is very faithful to the comic. I should also note that these films were pretty
much my first experience with X-Men, I knew of the comics and the animated
series which I didn’t start watching until after seeing X-Men: The Last Stand.
This superhero franchise is about people
known as mutants who are each born with a special gift, due to the next stage
of evolution. This explores the theme of prejudice, humans vs. mutants. This is an allegory to real-life prejudices that have gone on the world
i.e. racism, in fact the leader characters Professor Xavier and Magneto are
often compared to Martin Luther King and Malcolm X.
The mutants and their gifts include:
Wolverine – rapid-healing and retractable claws; Professor Xavier – telepathy
and mind control; Magneto – manipulate metal; Jean Grey – telekinesis and
telepathy; Cyclops – laser eyes; Storm – weather manipulation; Rogue –
absorption of life force and mutant powers through touch; Mystique – shape
shifter; Nightcrawler – teleportation; Iceman – ice powers; Shadowcat – phase
through solid objects; Beast – animal-like physical attributes; Quicksilver –
super speed and so much more…
X-Men
Excellent first installment to the
franchise, it does an excellent job at introducing the characters and their
abilities as well as the social commentary. Not the best installment but it is
exactly what an X-Men movie needs to be, our X-Men battling against the Brotherhood
mutants trying achieve the same thing, which is to overcome the prejudice inflicted
on them from humans.
Hugh Jackman here makes his
star-making performance as Wolverine and defined the role as his own, that it’s
so hard to imagine who could takeover after he retires the role. Patrick Stewart
and Ian McKellen are excellent as Xavier and Magneto, when you see them
together you can sense the years of conflict but also respect they had for each
other, that you can see this is no standard good vs. evil story. Famke Janssen
and James Marsden make a good support as Jean Grey and Cyclops, Halle Berry
while she does try is miscast as Storm. The standout to
me however is Anna Paquin as Rogue. Yes, I know she’s not the same tough,
kick-ass woman from the comic and animated series and it’s underwhelming that
she was downgraded to a vulnerable teenage girl. But I do think vulnerable can
be just as interesting as strong, by stripping away all the strength we are
left with a sympathetic character who is afraid of her own power, she can’t
touch anyone without causing serious harm to them. They do a great job using
the character to portray the tragedy of being a mutant. Anna Paquin does an
amazing job at playing that soft side of the character, I felt so sorry for
this character. Every time she was onscreen I just wanted to hug her, even if
it killed me. Another scene-stealer is Rebecca Romijn as Mystique, a blue-scaly
henchwoman to Magneto with amazing acrobatic fighting skills, Romijn demands so
much attention without any dialogue, seriously she has only one line in this
film.
The action is still great even some
slightly dated special effects, Wolverine’s fight with Sabretooth on top of
Statue of Liberty is still breathtaking.
X-Men 2 or X2
Our heroes and villains have to work
together as William Stryker has a plan that will kill all the mutants in the
world. It's cool seeing how all the characters interact with each other, especially
Magneto and Mystique with Wolverine and Rogue after what they’ve put them
through in the first film but now they have to be civil despite their detest.
Hugh Jackman gets to expand
Wolverines character as he gets to explore his past and confront it. Patrick
Stewart and Ian McKellen continue to be brilliant. Halle Berry while still
miscast as Storm does a better job as she gets more to do, James Marsden sadly
wasted here as Cyclops. Famke Janssen gets to more time to shine as Jean, as
she is struggling to control her powers. Anna Paquin gets to continue Rogue’s
struggle for human contact with her relationship with Iceman. Speaking of which
Shawn Ashmore gets to more to do as Iceman, as he has to tell his family he’s a
mutant. Brian Cox does a great job as Stryker, despite being an evil character
there is a tragic backstory regarding his family to stop him 1-dimensional
villain, Stryker's connection to Wolverine's past was brilliantly handled. But we can’t talk about this film without talking about Alan
Cumming as Nightcrawler. What an awesome character, he is fun but also tragic. The
heavily detailed make-up on Mystique was already impressive but they did with
Nightcrawler tops it with the self-inflicted scar patterns. Cumming is absolutely
amazing, it’s almost a crime that he did not reprise his role any of the
sequels.
Nightcrawler’s attack at the Whitehouse is
one the best scenes in the franchise.
There are other stand-out action scene like
Stryker’s infiltration of the school and the fight between Wolverine and Lady
Deathstrike.
X-Men:
The Last Stand
While this has flaws, I do not think this
is a bad film by any means. The biggest problem I have is that there are too
many characters and it should’ve been longer, so some of them could’ve
benefitted with more screen time. What saves this film for me is the chances it
took, they had to have known a lot of fans would rage against these decisions but
they were worth taking the risk for.
It didn’t bother me that certain characters were
killed in the first half, not only is this one of the few superhero films with
the balls to kill off big characters but it also raises the stakes.
Yes it does kind of suck that Mystique
loses her powers and Magneto’s abandonment of her is heartbreaking. The scene
is successful, not only does it make you feel sorry for a villain but the sight
of Rebecca Romijn naked does not detract from it.
Rogue taking the cure has annoyed a lot of
the fans, I’m not bothered so much because her tragic arc justifies her doing
so. The film doesn’t set out that taking the cure was the right thing or wrong
thing, it was just a decision that has to be respected, as she says “It’s what
I wanted”. It should also noted there is an episode in the animated where Rogue
was considering getting her powers taken away which she didn’t go ahead with.
So I praise this film taking that chance with her going through with it.
Hugh Jackman is awesome as usual, as well
as the returning cast Patrick Stewart, Rebecca Romijn, Anna Paquin, Shawn
Ashmore, James Marsden. Both Ian Mckellen and Halle Berry get the chance to
upgrade their performances as Magento and Storm. New to the cast – Kelsey Gramer
as Beast is absolutely perfect in the role, Ellen Page as Shadowcat, Ben Foster
as Angel whom is wasted but is a great casting choice, Vinnie Jones as
Juggernaut. It is Famke Janssen however who steals the show as Jean Grey and
the Dark Phoenix. There’s been a lot of complaints the Phoenix saga wasn't done justice, honestly I didn’t know anything about it before seeing the film so as a
first-timer I enjoyed this plot. It was an interesting look at multiple
personalities and how far someone can be pushed to breaking point. It’s a look
at consequences of taking regretful actions- Professor X, trying psychically
contain the Phoenix, thinking he’s doing the right thing but ends up making it
worse. Famke Janssen doesn’t overplay it with shouting or laughing, she plays
it with subtlety and successes at being both scary and sympathetic.
The whole climax is fantastic from
Magneto moving the Golden Gate Bridge to Wolverine’s tough decision at the end.
The Grey house scene with Phoenix vs Xavier, Wolverine vs Juggernaut and Storm
vs Callisto while the house rises is amazing, had me on the edge my seat-
easily my favourite scene in the whole franchise.
X-Men
Origins: Wolverine
This is the only X-Men film I really don’t like, I
don’t see any point to this prequel. The film starts off fine from Logan
discovering his claws for the first time as a child to his relationship to his
brother to meeting Stryker. But from then on it all goes downhill. The scene
where he was injected with adamantium was incredibly underwhelming, I
understand it would be too scary to show to a general audience. But it’s
heavily toned down compared to the very brief but intense flashbacks from
the first two films, that it doesn’t match up at all. Also the trauma he
would’ve suffered was hardly portrayed, I always thought the mass amount of trauma from
such a procedure would’ve caused his amnesia, but no! There’s more plot so,
Wolverine just gets over it as we another plot to go through. The said plot is
pretty much just a rehash of X-Men 2, followed by the dumbest explanation how
he loses his memory. Apart from a bit of the first act nothing about this prequel
adds anything to Wolverine’s backstory that was worth knowing or that we already
learnt from X-Men 2. Since Wolverine never remembers the events of the film –
then why should we?
There are no stakes in this in this film,
not only do we know where Stryker’s plot is going but also we are never
worried about Wolverine since he can’t die therefore no danger or threat.
Anything to like? I did like Liev Shreiber
as Sabretooth and the film did provide something for Ryan Reynold’s eventual
true depiction of Deadpool to stamp on.
X-Men:
First Class
I really like this film but I disagree with
the reviews that call this the best and even calling it The Dark Knight of the
X-Men films.
This has created a lot of plot holes to the
first three films, that it was very difficult to determine if this was a
genuine prequel or a proper reboot.
Jennifer Lawrence and Nicolas Hault are
very talented and are good choices as young Mystique and Beast, but the writing for
the characters are inconsistent that it makes it very difficult connect them to
adult versions played by Rebecca Romijn and Kelsey Grammer.
James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender are
truly what keeps this film going, they take the characters of Professor X and Magneto
and make them their own while still honoring Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen.
Plus Wolverine has an awesome cameo.
The
Wolverine
Now this is how to do a spin-off for
Wolverine, it fixes the big problem – it puts Wolverine in danger.
Hugh Jackman has been the show stealer for all
the previous installments, even his small cameo in First Class was awesome
enough to steal an entire film. But this is Hugh Jackman’s best portrayal of
the character to date. Apparently the Japan saga in the comics that this film
is based on is Hugh Jackman’s favourite and it really shows. It was great to
see these multiple sides to the character that we haven’t seen before. The
biggest problem though is that it tries to be a stand-alone while still trying
to connect itself to the series, one minute
it’s serious and gritty and the next it’s silly and over the top, that at
times it feels like we are watching two films at the same time.
X-Men:
Days Of Future Past
By far the best of the franchise! This is
an example of a sequel that takes flaws and plot holes of the previous
installment(s) and turn them into positives. It’s also usually a bad sign to introduce time-travel this late into a franchise, but it works.
The future is in a terrible place as
humanity is under control of the Setinels, robots designed to kill mutants.
Their only hope is to go back to the 1970’s and stop Mystique from
assassinating Boliver Trask, the creator. How? Shadowcat’s power can now phase
other people’s minds through time, they send older Wolverine’s mind to younger
Wolverine, Hugh Jackman plays both as Wolverine ages slowly.
James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender get to
expand their roles even further, especially McAvoy as Xavier has hit
rock-bottom. Jennifer Lawrence and Nicolas
Hault get to show their talents this time as Mystique and Beast, especially
Jennifer this is where I truly sympathized with Mystiques character but also
gets plenty of fight scenes to be almost as awesome Romijn’s Mystique.
Of the original cast returning besides Hugh
Jackman, we have Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellan, Halle Berry, Ellen Page, Shawn
Ashmore and many more. They are all welcome returns, sadly they don’t get as
much screen time as before but they still have their moments.
New to the cast is Peter Dinklage as
Boliver Trask, for such a small guy it’s so believable how he has so much
power. Evan Peters as Quicksilver is excellent and has one of the best
slow-motion actions ever.
The contrast of the future and the past is
excellent; the future is pretty dark and cold while the past is quite light and
warm.
The Rogue Cut is the true version of the
film, not only does add back in Anna Paquin’s Rogue, whom doesn't appear in the theatrical
cut, but it helps flesh out other characters, especially the original cast and
adds more action as well.
X-Men:
Apocalypse
I was skeptical about this actually
because after Days Of Future Past I wanted to see a continuation of the new
future with the original cast not the new cast. The reviews for this film were
also not very complimentary. But I was thoroughly entertained by this. I
thought the younger cast were excellent Sophie Turner as Jean Grey, Tye
Sheridan as Cyclops, Kodi Smit-McPhee as Nightcrawler and Alexandra Shipp as
Storm do fantastic jobs at capturing their predecessor portrayals while still
making them their own. Oscar Isaac as Apocalypse was very menacing, maybe a little
2-dimensional but still awesome. The returning cast are great as usual,
Jennifer Lawrence and Nicolas Hault have slightly less to do, Evan Peters as
Quicksilver however gets more to do. Rose Byrne makes a welcome return as
Moira, while Olivia Munn and Ben Hardy as Psylocke and Angel are good with the
very little they have to do. James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender are again
top-notch as Xavier and Magneto.
The whole climax was amazing and every
one of the characters had their fair contributions to it. Probably not the most
thought provoking of the X-Men films but certainly one of the more entertaining
ones.
Also Wolverine has another cameo, one
that puts the Origins movie to shame.
I’m not going to be discussing Deadpool as I feel that’s a topic for a
separate review. I know it goes without saying but, it’s awesome!
This is certainly one of my favourite
superhero movie franchises, dare I say I love this even more than the Marvel
Cinematic Universe? Actually yes I do. Not saying these are better movies, I’m
just saying these connected with me more on a personal level.